The short answer: AI tools recommend contractors they can find, check and describe. They lean on your website, your Google Business Profile, review sites like Yelp, and “best of” lists. And the answer depends a lot on where the person asking is standing.
We know because we tested it on ourselves. Scroll is a marketing agency for home service businesses in Salt Lake City. On November 15, 2026, we asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews to recommend an agency like us, from 27 different spots in three cities. Here’s what came back, and what it means if you run a roofing, HVAC or other home service company.
What we tested
We used Local Falcon, a tool that asks AI platforms the same question as if the person were standing at different points on a map. Each scan used a grid of 9 points within 5 miles of a city center.
- Salt Lake City, where our office and Google Business Profile are: five prompts, including “best marketing agency for home service businesses,” “home service marketing agency” and “best marketing agency for roofers.”
- Dallas and Phoenix, where we have no office: two prompts, “best marketing agency for home service businesses” and “best marketing agency for roofers.”
- Platforms: ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Google AI Overviews.
That came to 33 AI scans and 297 AI answers, all on the same afternoon.
What we found
At home, ChatGPT named us most of the time
For “best marketing agency for home service businesses,” ChatGPT named Scroll in 7 of 9 answers around Salt Lake City, and put us first in 5 of them. For “home service marketing agency,” Google AI Overviews named us at 6 of 9 points and AI Mode at 3 of 9.
Narrow questions were harder
When the question got more specific, we mostly disappeared. For “best marketing agency for roofers,” ChatGPT named us at 1 of 9 points in Salt Lake City. For HVAC and solar agency prompts, no AI tool named us at all. Gemini didn’t name us in any of its 45 Salt Lake City answers.
Away from home, we didn’t exist
In Dallas and Phoenix, across all four AI tools, Scroll was named in 0 of 126 answers. Same company, same website, same day. The only thing that changed was where the question came from.
Why ChatGPT named us in Salt Lake City
We read every ChatGPT answer that named us. In all 7, joinscroll.com was among the sources ChatGPT listed. Four of them quoted our published prices, like “Published plans from $1,250/month for managed marketing.” Two quoted a case study from our website: Rocky Mountain Garage Pros, $313,000 in closed revenue from 87 jobs in Q1 2026.
Our read: the AI repeated facts that were specific, public and easy to check. A price. A named client. A city. It didn’t repeat slogans.
Who got named instead
In Dallas and Phoenix, the 126 answers named other agencies instead. The most-named included Hook Agency (in 92 answers), RYNO Strategic Solutions (61), Scorpion (52), Blue Corona (42) and Roofing Webmasters (36, all on the roofers prompt).
Those lists matter. Across all 297 answers, “best agencies” comparison pages were some of the most-cited sources. We checked 30 of the most-cited list pages, including the 26 cited most often. Scroll wasn’t on any of them.
What a bigger study says
Our test is one business on one day. BrightLocal ran a much larger one. Their study of AI local search (September 2026) tracked 1,342 business locations, about 200,000 prompts and 1,967,762 citations across ChatGPT, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews. A few findings that matter for contractors:
- Your website still matters most. Business websites made up 42% of all citations.
- Google Business Profile is the next biggest source. It made up 28.5% of citations, and Google’s two AI tools lean on it heavily. ChatGPT barely uses it.
- ChatGPT leans on Yelp and Bing. Yelp was 9.5% of all citations. Facebook was 2.2% and BBB 0.33%.
- Answers are short lists. ChatGPT named 4.1 businesses per answer on average, AI Mode 3.5 and AI Overviews 2.5.
- Answers change. Running the same prompt again gave only 20 to 33% overlap. A business that showed up once came back about half the time.
- Ranking on Google Maps isn’t the same as AI visibility. Maps named a tracked business in 66% of searches; the AI tools did in 32 to 38%.
This isn’t brand new
Google has used machine learning to read what searchers mean for years. RankBrain is the example most SEO people know. What changed is that the AI now writes the answer itself and names a handful of businesses, instead of showing ten links and letting the homeowner choose.
What to do about it if you’re a contractor
- Make your facts match everywhere. Same business name, address, phone, hours and services on Google Business Profile, Yelp, Facebook, BBB, Bing Places and Apple Business Connect. AI tools compare these sources.
- Put checkable facts on your website. One page per service. The towns you serve. Real jobs with real numbers. Prices or starting prices, if you’re comfortable publishing them. That’s what ChatGPT quoted about us.
- Answer the questions homeowners ask, on the page. “Do you do insurance claims?” “Do you finance?” “How long does a replacement take?” Write the answer in plain words.
- Keep reviews coming on Google and Yelp, and reply to them.
- Set up Bing. Claim Bing Places and add your site to Bing Webmaster Tools. ChatGPT draws on Bing.
- Don’t block AI crawlers by accident. Check your robots.txt and any security or firewall setting that blocks bots.
- Get on the lists. If local or trade “best of” lists exist for your area, ask to be reviewed. Send facts they can check. Don’t pay for placement.
- Check your own answers every month. Ask the same few questions from your own area, and write down who gets named and which sites get cited.
And skip the shortcuts. Fake reviews, fake Reddit accounts and anyone selling “guaranteed ChatGPT placement” will cost you more than they earn. Nobody can guarantee an AI answer.
What we’re doing next
We’re taking our own advice: fixing our listings, publishing trade pages with real numbers and asking list editors to review us. We’ll run the same scans again in mid-December and mid-January and update this page with what changed, good or bad.
The limits of this test
One business, one day, one 9-point grid per city per prompt. Local Falcon simulates a searcher’s location; real people get personalized answers. And as BrightLocal found, the same question asked twice can get a different list. Treat our numbers as a snapshot, not a law.
If you want this done for your business, it’s part of our AI SEO work for home service companies, alongside local SEO. Our roofing, HVAC and builder results are on our case studies page.

